This was my original attempt to illustrate how **problems can be solved** with Polycentric cooperation and coordination.
See EIP Sketch
See Geopolitical Rhythms. See Geopolitical Scale. See Geopolitical Subsidiarity. See Geopolitical Subsidiarity. See Family Farm Eco Pol Net 2 See Communicating Bottom to Top
Decisions (politics) are constrained by place, time, and distance as well as affiliations. These must be made explicit for **good decision making** and transparency.
There are a set of **nesting geopolitical systems** that have evolved to handle complex societal situations/problems. One can add or subtract from this tentative list, depending on what complex system one is interested in managing.
digraph G { rankdir=BT subgraph cluster0 {label = "VSM Levels (recursions)"; node [style=filled, color=aquamarine]; style=filled; color=lightgrey; {Individual -> {Association Family rank=same} -> Neighborhood -> Town -> City -> CountyWatershed -> State -> Region -> Nation -> Continent -> World [label="EV" color=blue penwidth=2]} } subgraph cluster0 {label = "VSM Levels (recursions)"; node [style=filled, color=aquamarine]; style=filled; color=lightgrey; {World -> Continent -> Nation -> Region -> State -> CountyWatershed -> City -> Town -> Neighborhood -> {Association Family} -> Individual [label="EV" color=red penwidth=2]} } // subgraph cluster1 {label = "Sources of Health"; node [style=filled];style=filled; color=white; SocialServices -> EnvironmentalSafety -> Mobility -> SocialInteraction -> Curosity -> EducationalAttainment -> ParksTrailsPaths -> PreventionProtection -> HealthyFoodDietAtHome -> OTCDrugs -> DentalCare -> Nutrition -> AlternativeMedicine -> TrafficSafety -> HomeSafety -> RollBalance -> MentalHealth; color="#00c3ff" } // subgraph cluster2 {label = "Healthy Systems" node [style=filled, color=azure]; style=filled; color=yellow; HealthyIndividual -> HealthyFamily -> HealthyNeighborhood -> HealthyTown -> HealthyCity -> HealthyCountyWaterShed -> HealthyState -> HealthyRegion -> HealthyNation -> HealthyContinent -> HealthyWorld; } // subgraph cluster5 {label = "MedicalSystemComponents"; node [style=filled, color=aquamarine]; style=filled; color=lightgrey; DME -> Robotics -> RxDrugs -> ProcedureSurgery -> CommunicationTech -> Sensors -> Facilities -> Skills } // subgraph cluster3 {label = "Sick Systems" node [style=filled, color=azure]; style=filled; color=pink; IllIndividual -> IllFamily -> IllNeighborhood -> IllTown -> IllCity -> IllCountyWaterShed -> IllState -> IllRegion -> IllNation -> IllContinent -> IllWorld; } // subgraph cluster4 {label = "Sources of Dis-ease" node [style=filled, color=bisque]; style=filled; color=red; Misinformation -> Racism -> Poverty -> Fear -> LowEducationalAttainment -> Conflict -> Greed -> NeoliberalEconomicsRichGetRicher -> Enclosure ; label = "Sources of Dis-ease"} //start -> EnvironmentalSafety //start -> HealthyIndividual; //start -> Individual //start -> IllIndividual; //start -> Misinformation // HealthyWorld -> end // World -> end // IllWorld -> end //start [shape = Mdiamond] // end [shape=Msquare] // subgraph cluster6 {label = "Security System" Insurance -> HouseholdSecurity -> NeighborhoodWatch -> TownPolice -> CityPolice -> CountySheriff ->StatePolice -> NationalGuard -> NationalMilitary -> WorldPolice} // subgraph cluster7 {label = "PubHealth System" {NeighborhoodCommHealthWorkerCoord -> CityPublicHealth -> CountyPublicHealth -> StatePublicHealth -> NationalPublicHealth ->WorldPublicHealth [label = EV]}} // subgraph cluster8 {label = "Economic System" {HomeEconomics -> NeighborhoodEconomicSystem -> CityEconomicSystem -> CountyEconomicSystem -> RegionEconomicSystem -> StateEconomicSystem -> NationalEconomicSystem -> WorldEconomicSystem [label = EV]}} // subgraph cluster9 {label = "Finance System" {NeighborhoodFinanceSystem -> CountyFinanceSystem -> StateFinanceSystem -> NationalFinanceSystem -> WorldFinanceSystem [label = EV]}} // subgraph cluster10 {label = "Court System" {MunicipalCourt -> CountyCourt-> StateCourt -> FederalCourt -> SupremeCourt -> WorldCourt [label = EV]}} // subgraph cluster11 {label = "Food System" {HouseholdGardens -> CommunityGardens -> Farms -> Markets -> GroceryStores [label = EV]}} // subgraph cluster12 {label = "Medical Care" {MotherHealthRole -> HomeFirstAid -> NeighborhoodCommHealthWorker -> EMS -> Pharmacies -> Clinic -> Hospital -> TirtiaryCare -> QuaternaryCare [label = EV]}} // subgraph cluster13 {label = "Safe Behaviors" SafeSex -> Food -> Drugs -> Noise -> Kenetic-> Social-> Thought-> Online } // subgraph cluster14 {label = "Land Use" {Forests -> Commons -> Homesteads -> Aggriculture -> Recreation -> Roads -> CommercialLand [label = EV]}} // subgraph cluster15 {label = "Energy" {Nuclear -> Electromagnetic -> Heat -> Chemical ->Kinetic -> Electric -> Ionizing [label = EV]} } // subgraph cluster16 {label = "Polution" {IndividualPolution -> HouseholdPolution -> NeighborhoodPolution -> TownPolution -> CityPolution -> CountyPolution -> StatePolution -> RegionalPolution -> NationalPolution -> WorldPolution [label = EV]}} // subgraph cluster17 {label = "Finance System" { Gifts -> Exchange -> Barter -> Currency -> Equity -> LoansDebt [label = EV]}} // subgraph cluster18 {label = "Economic System" Demand -> Production -> Use -> Surplus -> Market} // Individual -> {Online Social Kinetic Noise Drugs Mobility EducationalAttainment Curosity Online IndividualPolution ParksTrailsPaths SafeSex Food} [color=Red] // Family -> {Online Social Kinetic Noise Drugs Food MotherHealthRole HomeEconomics HouseholdGardens HouseholdPolution HouseholdSecurity ParksTrailsPaths} [color=Blue] // Neighborhood -> {Social Kinetic Noise Drugs NeighborhoodEconomicSystem Food NeighborhoodFinanceSystem CommunityGardens Clinic Pharmacies NeighborhoodPolution GroceryStores NeighborhoodWatch} [color=green] // Town -> {Social Hospital TownPolution TownPolice} [color=orange] // City -> {Social Kinetic CityPublicHealth TirtiaryCare CityPolution MunicipalCourt CityPolice} [color=orchid1] // CountyWatershed -> {Social CountyPublicHealth CountyEconomicSystem CountyFinanceSystem Farms CountySheriff CountyCourt CountyPolution} // State -> {Kinetic StatePublicHealth StateEconomicSystem StatePolution StateFinanceSystem Insurance StatePolice NationalGuard StateCourt} [color=sienna] // Region -> { } [color=slateblue1] // Nation -> {Online Kinetic NationalPublicHealth NationalPolution NationalEconomicSystem NationalFinanceSystem NationalMilitary FederalCourt SupremeCourt} [color=steelblue3] // Continent -> {} [color=tomato] // World -> {WorldFinanceSystem WorldEconomicSystem WorldPublicHealth WorldCourt WorldPolice WorldPolution} [color=turquoise3] }
Think of each arrows labeled "EV" in the diagrams as absent choices, as **Requests for Help**. Ask who is best able to understand the problem and best able to participate in the solution in some particular way.
# It is unusual that any one level can completely take care of a complex problem without interplay with levels above and below.
People participating at each level need more than the often recommended three level awareness.
We must know the most salient aspects of each level. This is knowledge of what is or could be happening at these other levels in order for the focal level to thrive and participate with the other levels.
I see no reason that we cannot become comfortable with metasystemic properties such as Meta Concepts, Meta Languages, Metasystems, and their very different wavelengths or time durations of change.
There is a major imbalance in how we approach problem solving among the three major approaches: Civil (commons-local), Private (business-local to global), and Public (government-local to global). Ostrom's idea of polycentricity and Polycentric Networks is key in integrating all three forms of problems solving. # We must analyze every problem and ask what geopolitical scales need to participate in the solution.
The question to ask is always, "What is it that a particular level cannot manage well and what level can best help in the long run."
The critical rule is to take care of everything at the lowest (most practical) level. (Subsidiarity)
Often **fear or hurry** cause lower levels to ask for help when they could have better taken care instead of asking for help.
Often fear and hurry lead higher levels to impose poorly fitting policies and constraints on lower, more practical levels.
Try to avoid requests-that-weaken and helping-that-harms.
Help with problem solving goes both directions. Where the highest variety resides depends upon what kinds of systems are being considered.
.
Open the page links below or play with the graph below. Click on some of the recursions (nodes in the graph). These subgraphics are illustrative, not accurate nor complete.
Individual Perspective bottom-up version of excess variety.
World Perspective top-down version of excess variety which risk being misleading.
Combined Perspective of Individual up and World down which may create more confusing.
.
See Geopolitical Rhythms pending. See Geopolitical Scale. See Geopolitical Subsidiarity.
# It will be informative to apply this analysis to all 17 of the UN's Sustainable Development Goals.
DOT strict digraph rankdir=LR node [shape=box style="solid,rounded,filled" fillcolor=lightyellow penwidth=3 color=red] HERE NODE node [style="solid,rounded,filled" fillcolor=white penwidth=3 color=blue] edge [style=solid penwidth=1 color=black] BACKLINKS NODE -> HERE node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=5 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=8 color=grey] HERE BACKLINKS NODE -> HERE STATIC strict digraph {rankdir=LR node [shape=box style="solid,rounded,filled" fillcolor=lightyellow penwidth=3 color=red] "Geopolitical Recursions" node [style="solid,rounded,filled" fillcolor=white penwidth=3 color=blue] edge [style=solid penwidth=1 color=black] "A More Cybernetic US Government?" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "A Pattern Language of Conversational Types" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Designing for Requisite Variety" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Economy in Geo Bio Political Recursions" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Editing Page" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Ethical Scales" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Ethical Scales Template" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Finance and Fairness" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Geopol Subsidiarity Diagram" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Geopolitical Commons" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Geopolitical Scale" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Geopolitical Subsidiarity" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Governing" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Inventing Governing: Summary" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Marc Pierson's Use of VSM" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Marc's Education Pages" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Meta" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Mission Critical Functions" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Narrowing Choice Usefully" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "RE LOCALIZE" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Requisite Democracy" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Responsibility-Capability" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "Sofi VSM" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" "When and Where" -> "Geopolitical Recursions" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Economy in Geo Bio Political Recursions" -> "A More Cybernetic US Government?" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Critical Conversation Types" -> "A Pattern Language of Conversational Types" "Six Hats Pathway" -> "A Pattern Language of Conversational Types" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "A More Cybernetic US Government?" -> "Economy in Geo Bio Political Recursions" "Ecological Economics" -> "Economy in Geo Bio Political Recursions" "Economy in Geo Bio Political Recursions" -> "Economy in Geo Bio Political Recursions" "Geopol Subsidiarity Diagram" -> "Economy in Geo Bio Political Recursions" "Geopolitical Subsidiarity" -> "Economy in Geo Bio Political Recursions" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Horizons" -> "Ethical Scales" "Politics (Ethics-- ought)" -> "Ethical Scales" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "My Template List" -> "Ethical Scales Template" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "A More Cybernetic US Government?" -> "Geopol Subsidiarity Diagram" "Economy in Geo Bio Political Recursions" -> "Geopol Subsidiarity Diagram" "Geopol Subsidiarity Diagram" -> "Geopol Subsidiarity Diagram" "Geopolitical Subsidiarity" -> "Geopol Subsidiarity Diagram" "Mission Critical Functions" -> "Geopol Subsidiarity Diagram" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Commons" -> "Geopolitical Commons" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Geopolitical Recursions" -> "Geopolitical Scale" "Law of Multi-Scale Requisite Variety" -> "Geopolitical Scale" "Scale" -> "Geopolitical Scale" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Geopol Subsidiarity Diagram" -> "Geopolitical Subsidiarity" "Geopolitical Recursions" -> "Geopolitical Subsidiarity" "Nested Ecosystems" -> "Geopolitical Subsidiarity" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Economy in Geo Bio Political Recursions" -> "Governing" "Geopol Subsidiarity Diagram" -> "Governing" "Gov Mgmt" -> "Governing" "Inventing Governing: Intro" -> "Governing" "Inventing Governing: Summary" -> "Governing" "Rule of Development" -> "Governing" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Inventing Governing: 5" -> "Inventing Governing: Summary" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Empirical Research Review of the VSM" -> "Marc Pierson's Use of VSM" "Governing" -> "Marc Pierson's Use of VSM" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Teach & Implement Journalism in FedWiki" -> "Marc's Education Pages" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Economy in Geo Bio Political Recursions" -> "Meta" "Nesting Recursive Emerging Meta Systems" -> "Meta" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Critical Basic Needs Resorted" -> "Mission Critical Functions" "RE LOCALIZE" -> "Mission Critical Functions" "See Systems for Civic Action" -> "Mission Critical Functions" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Essential Needs" -> "RE LOCALIZE" "PROGRAMS" -> "RE LOCALIZE" "RE LOCALIZE" -> "RE LOCALIZE" "ReLocalize" -> "RE LOCALIZE" "ReLocalize Creativity" -> "RE LOCALIZE" "See Systems for Civic Action" -> "RE LOCALIZE" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Marc Pierson's Use of VSM" -> "Responsibility-Capability" "Responsibility-Capability" -> "Responsibility-Capability" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Integrating Models" -> "Sofi VSM" "Neighborhood Systems Patterns" -> "Sofi VSM" node [style="dotted,rounded,filled" penwidth=1 fillcolor=white color=grey] edge [style=dotted penwidth=5 color=grey] "Pattern Language of Conversations" -> "When and Where" "Questions that Reveal Systems" -> "When and Where" "Six Nested Questions" -> "When and Where"}